There is no doubt that West Ham’s pre-season has shaped up very well so far. Carlton Cole looks proficient playing in a lone striker role and has already contributed a couple of goals. In addition, he has received good quality support from Boa Morte and Freddie Sears on the left and right side of the forward line. The defence has looked tight and disciplined and the central midfield combination of Noble and Hitzlsperger has done extremely well.
Moreover, Having read accounts of the Brossia MGB and Panathinaikos matches, not only have the team played good football, but they have shown a creditable discipline and professionalism in adapting to a new formation. Grant’s management will probably see a move away from 4-4-2 and the adoption of a far more flexible 4-3-3 or even 4-2-3-1 formation. Personally, I hope that we go for the 4-2-3-1 that was prevalent tactically in the recent World Cup Finals. This would probably see Noble and Parker partnered in central midfield, with a combination of Barrera, Boa Morte, Hitzlsperger, Stanislas, Sears, Diamanti (if he stays?), Collison (when fit) or Remy (if he ever actually signs?) or Hines supporting Cole at the fulcrum of the attack.
It is the ability of this bank of three forwards to give close support to Cole and regularly hit the back of the net that will ultimately determine the success of the formation. The players referred to above are all more than capable of delivering goals. In that respect the performances of Hitzlsperger have been particularly encouraging. ‘Das Hammer’ has started to show an ability to score goals from deep positions and that is to be warmly welcomed. Last season, Diamanti weighed in with eight or nine goals, but he was the exception in a midfield that did not hit the target nearly regularly enough.
There has been a lot of press speculation about the exit of Parker and Cole to Aston Villa and Stoke City respectively. Personally, I would not welcome the departure of either player. They are part of the team’s spine and their loss will probably weaken it. However, I am also more than aware that one or more ’star’ players may need to be sacrificed to provide the funds for further new arrivals. And it does seem likely that space in the striker berths will need to be found if the rumours concerning the imminent arrival of Argentinian prospect, Caragilo, are true?
It would be a great pity though, as in Cole, Picquionne and Nouble we have three excellent options to play at the apex of our new formation. Whilst selling Cole to accommodate Caragilo, a young player untried in the PL, would represent a gamble. If it comes off then it will be hailed as a master stroke, if it does not then we could all come to regret it. Decisions such as that are the call of the management, it what they are very well paid for, and ultimately they stand or fall by them.
It is notable that the defence has been very tight so far, with players such as James Tomkins showing impressive early form. However, the principle question remains whether Upson wishes to stay with the club or seek pastures new? If he does go then we will need to recruit an experienced and high quality replacement. Also, will Clerc be signed to provide international quality cover at right-back? Will the restructure of the squad also mean that some defenders such as Gabbidon and Spector could be moved on before the start of the season?
Regardless, one of the features of the 4-2-3-1 is the way in which the system gives additional midfield cover to the defence, shielding it and giving the full-backs greater opportunity to get forward and provide vital width. These are features that will assist West Ham to overcome two of the worst faults from last season, the fragility of our defence and a lack of real width in our forward play.
It is a formation that interests me and I particularly like the tactical flexibility and movement that it tends to promote. It looks like Grant’s player recruitment is geared to providing the players to make it work. Lets hope that, unlike in the case of GF Zola’s squad last summer, the club has furnished/furnishes Grant with the players to ensure that the formation succeeds. Otherwise, there will probably be another hasty retreat back in to the comfort zone of a more rigid 4-4-2!
SJ. Chandos.